质量效应 2
Mass Effect 2

BioWare, 2010
Windows, Xbox 360 和 PS3

BioWare, 2010
Windows, Xbox 360 and PS3

质量效应(Mass Effect)已然成为一个叫好又叫座的作品,BioWare 在这之后又花费了三年时间来对其续作进行打磨。BioWare 和 Electronic Arts 无不为最终的成果感到高兴,因为无论在销量上还是口碑上《质量效应 2(Mass Effect 2)》都超越了其前作(Metacritic[1] 网站评分 89 vs 94)。但这部作品真的是一个更好的 RPG 作品吗?我对此持否定态度。

一个更好的游戏?也许吧。但它同时也是一个充满了矛盾的游戏,处处散发着惨遭公司管理层和制作委员会干预开发的气息。

游戏中的文本内容充分表现了这部游戏的矛盾性。游戏的主线剧情几乎可以在史上最烂剧情里排上号:在游戏开始时薛帕德(Shepard)死了,但随即就被一个恐怖组织复活并被迫为其工作,不断地为了一个特殊任务收集资源,拉拢盟友。因为槽点实在过多,我推荐读者直接阅读 Shamus Young 对游戏剧情的独到分析。

然而游戏中的重头戏在于对队友的塑造,包括他们的招募过程和忠诚任务。本作中对队友的刻画算得上 BioWare 作品中的标杆。虽然这些角色称不上特立独行,还多少有点工具化和刻板化的倾向,但每一个角色都被塑造的十分立体,呼之欲出。与之相关的招募任务和忠诚任务也都十分出彩。

The original Mass Effect was both a critical and a commercial success, and the BioWare team had three years to polish the sequel. Mass Effect 2 ended up selling more copies and winning more awards (Metacritic 89 vs. 94), so both BioWare and Electronic Arts were surely happy. But is it really a better RPG? My answer would be no.

A better game? Possibly. It's a paradoxical game, that suffers from what seems to be executive meddling and a design-by-committee approach.

The best element to showcase this schizophrenia is the writing. The main plot ranks among the worst video game plots in existence – it starts with Shepard getting killed, then resurrected and forced to work for a terrorist organisation, gathering allies and resources for a special mission. Its flaws are too many to list here and I recommend readers to check the excellent dissection by Shamus Young (linked to the left).

However, the companions and their recruitment and loyalty missions, which form the majority of the content, are some of BioWare's best. While the companions themselves are hardly unique and suffer from the “sexier and edgier” treatment, they are mostly well-written and the quests, first to recruit them and later to ensure their loyalty, are excellent.

Shamus Young 详尽地分析了《质量效应》三部曲的故事和世界观,并着重关注了从《质量效应》到《质量效应 2》的转变。这篇分析可以在他的网站中找到:www.shamusyoung.com

Writer Shamus Young wrote an extensive and detailed analysis of the Mass Effect trilogy's story and world-building, especially the changes from ME1 to ME2. It can be found on his website: www.shamusyoung.com

本作的技能学习系统相比前作有不少变化。对话和非战斗技能被移除了,但主角可以从队友身上学习新的技能。

Character-building has been changed. Dialogue and non-combat skills have been removed, but new powers can be learned from your companions.

比起前代,本作中的小队成员涵盖了银河系中更多的种族,游戏世界观也随着这些成员的故事进一步展开。不幸的是游戏初代中的百科词条被原封不动地搬了进来,用于帮助玩家了解剧情。但这完全没有必要,因为队友们已经说出玩家所需的一切信息了。

从技术角度讲,这部续作没有什么太明显的变化。以今天的眼光来看,游戏的音画表现仍然不错,只是游戏的关卡场景都略显狭小,那些齐腰高的掩体也总是在向玩家剧透即将在此处发生的战斗。

对我来说,《质量效应 2》最大的变化就是加入了与《战争机器(Gears of War)》(Gears of War)十分相似的掩体系统。我看不懂这个改变的意义,因为原版的战斗系统并没有什么问题。而且这一系统和特殊能力配合的不太好,进入掩体后生硬的视角操控令瞄准变的十分困难。

为了强化游戏的射击元素,原版中的武器冷却系统被移除了——欢迎回到换弹匣的时代!毫无疑问,这样的调整必然会引起没必要的吃书[2] ,而且这项改动也显得有些意义不明,因为游戏里遍地都是子弹,打都打不完。即使一个全程“突突突”的战士也不会遇到弹尽粮绝的危险。

不同职业的特殊能力和技能树也被大幅修改了。它们被改的无足轻重,也不如上一作中那样有趣。小队构成也变的无关紧要,因为你的队友在大部分战斗中都发挥不了什么作用。因为这些问题的存在,制作组又不得不将每个关卡都设计成适合任何职业的玩家。这一荼毒了《无冬之夜(Neverwinter Nights)》的设计在这部游戏中惨遭重演。

More races of the galaxy are represented in the team than were in the first Mass Effect, and through the companion stories the surrounding world is expanded. Unfortunately the encyclopaedia from the first game still exists and is utilised as a crutch by the writers – however it's unnecessary to actually consult it, as all the information that the player needs is conveyed by the companions.

Technically, the sequel has not made any notable changes. To this day, the game still looks and sounds good, though it is fairly obvious that the levels are small and the obvious waist-high walls are always a clear signpost that combat is about to start.

Which brings me to Mass Effect 2's big change: mechanically, the game has been turned into a cover shooter, similar to Gears of War. It's a puzzling change as mechanically there was nothing wrong in the combat of the original. It doesn't work too well with the special powers either, as aiming them is somewhat cumbersome with this new stiff camera.

To further reinforce the similarities to shooters, gone is the overheating mechanism – we're back to the safety of magazine reloads. Naturally, this change required a nonsensical retcon of existing lore and it really serves no purpose, as bullets are so liberally spread around that there is absolutely no danger of ever running dry, not even if you are a soldier and thus use guns for every encounter.

The special abilities of various classes and their skill trees have also been overhauled. They weren't that interesting in the original and now they are largely meaningless. Every encounter is possible to complete with any squad composition as your teammates are largely useless, thus levels had to be designed to accommodate every class that Shepard could be – a similar issue that plagued Neverwinter Nights.

__________

1 译者注:一个英文评分网站,会同时收集相关媒体和一般用户对于一部作品的评分。
2 译者注:虽然有些强行,但 BioWare 还是成功地在设定上把这个问题圆了回来,并且在之后的《质量效应:仙女座》中采用了多种换弹方式并存的设计。

GameDB 相关游戏: 质量效应 2

《电脑 RPG 游戏史(The CRPG Book Project)》原书信息

英文原版主编:Felipe Pepe
原项目网址:https://crpgbook.wordpress.com/
授权协议:知识共享 署名-非商业性使用 4.0 国际许可协议 (CC BY-NC 4.0)

这本书历时四年,由 119 名志愿者共同完成。

《CRPG 通鉴(The CRPG Book Project)》中文版版权说明

您正在看到的内容是《CRPG 通鉴》版本的一部分。
本中文版在原书授权协议的约束下进行创作与线上传播。

中文版编者:《CRPG 通鉴》编译委员会
中文版项目网址:https://crpgbook.cn

本书(《CRPG 通鉴》版本)正在筹备出版中文实体版,欢迎各路英豪加入我们编译委员会,详情请访问 这里

参与此中文 CRPG 文章的讨论

暂无关于此中文 CRPG 文章的评论。

您需要登录或者注册后才能发表评论
登录/注册